You make this trip often, so every minute matters. Between South Fork Commuter Connection trains and Hampton Jitney coaches, the fastest option changes with your schedule and the season. Use this guide to pick the route that reliably saves time door to door.
SFCC overview
The South Fork Commuter Connection pairs select LIRR Montauk Branch trains with local shuttles east of the Shinnecock Canal. It is built for weekday commuters with morning and afternoon connections. Check the latest SFCC trains and shuttle times on the official overview, and use the TrainTime app for live schedules and tickets (South Fork Commuter Connection).
Jitney overview
Hampton Jitney runs year round with multiple daily trips between Manhattan and Hamptons villages, including a Water Mill stop on Montauk Highway. Service frequency increases in peak seasons, and reservations are recommended. See current pickup points, Water Mill stop listings, and timetables on the schedule page (Hampton Jitney schedules).
Timing basics
In normal conditions, many riders see NYC to Water Mill on the Jitney in about 2 to 2.5 hours, with traffic adding variance (NYC to Water Mill travel time). Trains are less affected by highway congestion, so SFCC can be more predictable if your trip matches the designated train and shuttle windows. Your fastest route depends on the day and time you travel.
How SFCC works
You board an LIRR train west of the Canal and ride to an eastern station, then transfer to the SFCC shuttle for local stops. For Water Mill addresses, Bridgehampton is typically the closest active station, with Southampton as another option. Station details and connections are posted on the LIRR station pages (Bridgehampton Station info).
Key SFCC notes
- SFCC operates only on designated weekday trains with set shuttle connections.
- You need the SFCC ticket or voucher that matches those trains.
- Schedules are seasonal. Confirm shuttle times on official pages before you go (SFCC overview, Town shuttle details).
How the Jitney works
You reserve a seat online, meet the coach at a Manhattan pickup, and ride directly to Montauk Highway where the Water Mill stop is located. Onboard amenities commonly include Wi‑Fi, power outlets, and a lavatory on many coaches. Premium classes add comfort, and luggage travels in under‑floor compartments; review baggage rules before packing (Hampton Jitney baggage policy).
Last mile in Water Mill
The Jitney drops you right on Montauk Highway in Water Mill, often a short walk or quick car service to many homes. With SFCC, you will exit at Bridgehampton or Southampton and use the shuttle or a local ride to reach your address. Water Mill’s former LIRR station is not in service, so plan on a brief transfer from the nearest active stops (Water Mill station history).
Costs and tickets
SFCC uses LIRR tickets, and at times has offered discounted package tickets that include shuttle access. Buy on TrainTime or at station machines, and match your ticket to SFCC‑designated trains as outlined on official pages (SFCC overview). Jitney fares vary by class and booking timing, with online reservations usually offering the best value. Current prices and seat classes are listed on the schedule and booking pages (Hampton Jitney schedules).
When each option is faster
- Choose SFCC if you can travel during weekday peak windows, value predictable arrival times, and want to avoid highway traffic swings.
- Choose the Jitney if you need direct service to Water Mill’s Montauk Highway stop, are traveling outside SFCC hours, or prefer coach amenities.
- Mix it up. Test both on the same day of week and time, then track door‑to‑door results for your exact origin and address. The consistent winner for you is the one that beats traffic and trims transfers.
Quick decision guide
- Weekday morning to a Water Mill office: SFCC, if your train aligns with the shuttle.
- Friday afternoon in peak season: SFCC often wins on predictability if the timing fits.
- Late night or luggage‑heavy weekend: Jitney for direct drop and larger baggage capacity.
- Central Water Mill address near Montauk Highway: Jitney can save a transfer.
Ready to map this to your weekly routine or a second‑home schedule? Reach out for local timing advice that fits your exact location and season. If you are planning a purchase or sale, we will align showings and travel to keep your day efficient. Connect with Michael Petersohn to plan your next Hamptons trip and property strategy.
FAQs
Is there a direct LIRR stop in Water Mill?
- No. The old Water Mill station is no longer active. Use Bridgehampton or Southampton, then connect via shuttle or local ride (station history).
Where can I find official SFCC times?
- Check the MTA’s SFCC page for designated trains and shuttle links, and use TrainTime for live schedules (SFCC overview).
Does the Jitney stop in Water Mill?
- Yes. The schedule lists Water Mill on Montauk Highway. Confirm stop times and Manhattan pickups before you book (Jitney schedules).
Which is usually faster on summer Fridays?
- It depends on your timing. Trains avoid highway backups, so SFCC can be more consistent if your trip matches the designated windows. Coaches can take longer in heavy traffic (SFCC overview, travel time reference).
Can I bring large luggage?
- The Jitney has under‑floor compartments and posted baggage rules. SFCC shuttles are local buses with limited space, so pack lighter for those transfers (Jitney baggage policy).
